Latest Forum Topics / Biosensors | Post Reply |
Is Biosensors a good buy?
|
|||||
allright
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 22:57
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Haha Huatah I posted 1 second later than you.. Yes the pipeline for biomatrix - biolimus A9 has been laid. The thing is reading all that is posted, the CE mark is only the beginning. What i like is that the R& D by BIG is still high which means they are still advancing on NEW technology. One of the great hallmark of a successful company in the pharma industry | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
huatah
Veteran |
10-Jan-2008 22:32
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
hmm... allright.. u seems to post de same info as i just did.. lol.. was wondering whether we know ea other or not.. lol... if not.. how we got to noe it.. heehee | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|||||
huatah
Veteran |
10-Jan-2008 22:30
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
sori.. one more last thing.. de pipeline (in terms of wat it need to do) for BioMatrix has been laid. | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
allright
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 22:27
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Thank you and your comments noted Mr Investor . you are right. we shall only concentrate on the relevant and not on personal issues. I hope tomoro the price remains above .95 at least if my understanding of what you have written is correct. This however is the technical part. If there are any other good news then there is hope that the price is upwards. Will hold on to my shares as I BELIEVE in this share and up or down there is a great POTENTIAL after the CE mark as production and distribution will start immediately and this will be not only in Europe but in China, japan,Indonesia, Singapore and many other countries.... |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
huatah
Veteran |
10-Jan-2008 22:26
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Hi investor and bengster.. tks for all your feedback and detail analyzing. all shares.. fundamentally sound or watsoever.. will has its ups and downs.. even if tmr BIG had it's fall.. due to market sentiments.. due to macro forces.. there's nothing we could do... de most important things is wat we expect tis counter will b or to b down the road... Do we see future in tis stock.. if de answer is YES.. so wat.. if u vested at 1.02. If de answer is NO.. so wat if u secured at 0.67. For so many years (okie okie.. just 2yrs plus).. i hold tis stock when most ppl dun even wan to look at it.. today.. I couldn't believe de nos of postings within one single day - just like de volume today. I love tis stock.. cos it really assisted me to generate money.. and recuperate my losses in other counters.. (not an inducement to buy/sell/hold). Of course i will sell and buy-in again.. if not... how to make money.. but 50% will b holding on.. 50% will b in/out. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|||||
cashiertan
Elite |
10-Jan-2008 22:20
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Still holding on my remaining BIG shares. have areadly set sell limit on my saxotrader if BIG break the rising support trendline at 95c. gravestone candle formed, may expect some sell down. if break 95c i will auto exit this counter, will be looking forward to enter again when TA looks good again. Momentum after lunch dip, however it may be due to the STI glitch causing fear to market. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
investor
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 21:56
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Apologies for the error - The Axxion stent was generating about US$3m per qtr for Biosensors, initially, but subsequently went downhill. The Bio-matrix DES should be able to generate at leats 2-3 times that of the Axxion , maybe about US$6-9m per qtr, translating to about US$24m - US$36m per yr. (Gross profit margin should be greater than 50 %) Just my own personal opinion - Projection figures are conjectures based on my own perception of the DES standing in the medical world. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
cwwan1
Member |
10-Jan-2008 21:37
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Guru Bengster and mr investor, thanks for your contribution in this forum for BIG technical and finanical insight. | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|||||
singaporegal
Supreme |
10-Jan-2008 21:17
Yells: "Female TA nut" |
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
From the price action today, it seems like a very speculative stock or a counter that is controlled by BBs. This counter surged to a high price and then closed near its low. | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
investor
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 21:12
|
||||
x 2
x 0 Alert Admin |
It is obvious from all the analyst reports that they are beginning to LOOK at BIG in a NEW light. THis augurs well for BIG, and I think that once the CE mark is obtained, they might be a new round of upgrades. It was stated that JW Medical contributed US11.1 million for 9 mths 2007, but what was not stated is that US$5 million was contributed in Q3 2007. If you annualised it, JW Medical should contribute US$17m for 2007, and maybe US$20m or so in FY2008. (All figures assume full 100 % onwership of JW Medical, and BIG will only own 100 % somewhere down the road). Also, once CE mark is obtained, I think BIG should be able to generate sales of about US$6m per mth, ie about US$60m. I think this estimate is possible, as the Axxion stent, which is NOT a very good DES was able to generate US$3m per mth initally. (gross profit margin should be above 50 %). Excel gross profit margin is 70 % or so. Also, I think that BIG will be able to expand aggressively into the Asian countries (like India, indonesia, etc), as well as the Middle East and Latin American countries where the China SFDA approval for the Excel stent is recognised to mkt their product, which seems to be even better if not as good as the J & J cypher stent, bnut without the permanent polymer in place. (I infer all this from the BIG conference held yesterday - It did not come out of thin air) Also, Yoh Chi Lu (CEO) also mentioned that they are opened to more alliances, collaboration, even with Medtronics, who owned 15 % of Shandong Weigao, as the mkt for Asia is big, about US$800m, enough for all and growing rapidly. In fact, the CEO state that they aim to be the NO. 1 in Asia. All the above are my own personal opinion, and it NOT an inducement to BUY/SELL or Hold. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
investor
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 20:53
|
||||
x 2
x 2 Alert Admin |
I think that everyone is entitled to voice their opinions in this forum, whether you are bearish or bullish. The trick is not to step on each other's toes - each individual has their own sense of dignity, and when they feel that their right has been violated - they often react in a way, that will try to get back at the other party, by infuriating them. It is OK to say that Biosensors is a lousy stock, and that there is no book value, etc - It is ALSO OK to say that it is a very good stock, and that the future is bright - To each its own - That is what a forum is for. If we just state our views, WITHOUT resorting to name-calling, sarcasm - I think that things would not have got out of hand. OK, Back to the business at hand. Technically, If you draw a long-term downtrend line for Biosensors beginning from the top at 1.52 (Oct 2005) and connect to the top at 1.12 (in May 2006) and further down to connect the top at 0.995 (in Nov 2006) - you can see that Biosensors has cleared this down-trend line today. Obviously, BIG has also moved above all its moving averages recently in the last 2 weeks, which also looks good. Now for the bad part - today's poor closing has resulted in a 'shooting star' formation (or reverse hammer) - which MAY signify a top for the moment - BUT this signal (and most signals in Japanese candlestick) would need to be confirm by another day's action (tomorrow). Ideally, in the next few days, if the price can hold above this down-trend line (between 0.93 - 0.95), the chart pattern still looks bullish. In fact, the overall trend is still up, EVEN if it drops to 0.90 (or 0.895) on closing price. But if the price closes below 0.895, in the next few days - then it will look like the violation of a head and shoulder pattern, with the neckline at0.895, and most technical people would then expect it to drop to the region at 0.83 or so, which represents the 'gap' up, and even maybe further down. (have ro see the price action at that point) NOT a Call to Buy/Sell or Hold |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
Madnezz
Member |
10-Jan-2008 19:44
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
I think Brother Bengtser post is still better compare to those Analysts comment. Most of the comments came only after JWMS duel and not as details. | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
|
|||||
idesa168
Elite |
10-Jan-2008 19:41
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
THANK YOU! | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
allright
Senior |
10-Jan-2008 19:18
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Actually Bengster's text is not big. He has given us valuable information and they are all RELATED to Biosensors. He has posted us OCBC, UBS and earlier Cr Suisse analysts' comments. Thanks. really appreciate in depth coverage...also I like your ending ...not an inducement to buy etc.... In other words , we should read and make our own judgement. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
bengster68
Master |
10-Jan-2008 18:18
|
||||
x 0
x 1 Alert Admin |
OCBC Investment Research Biosensors Int?l Ltd Maintain BUY Previous Rating: BUY Fair Value: S$1.40JWMS acquisition makes good sense
(Biosensors) announced that it will be acquiring the remaining 50% of leading China based stent maker, JWMS, in 2 phases. The total acquisition values JWMS at about US$180m (about 11x FY07F PER) and Biosensors shareholders will experience approx 33% dilution when compared to FY07 fully diluted shares outstanding. However, Biosensors is now one of the select few, if not the only, listed interventional cardiology company worldwide with strong IP covering delivery system, drug, polymer and stent with a strong and profitable presence in a rapidly growing China market. See Table 1 for our JWMS projections. . Biosensors International GroupForesight will be rewarded. Biosensors is not myopic on selling its Biomatrix in the uncertain EU market where recent DES concerns have reduced its usage. China remains the largest market within Asia (ex-JP); accounting for half of the growing US$800m market and we believe that Biosensors has made the right initiative to pounce on this market concurrently through JWMS. We like this acquisition as it shows thatEating two pies concurrently able to address both spectrums of the government tenders in China. JWMS will market the Excel stent in the locally made (lower priced) and will be able to market Biomatrix (after regulatory clearance) under the imported (higher priced) medical products tenders. . With this acquisition, JWMS will now beValuation jumps. margin information about JWMS and Biosensors. Using standard medtech valuation (30% discount rate of FY10F net profit with average 30x peer PER, see also table 2 for valuation), fair value is raised to S$1.40 (vs. S$0.99). We maintain the discount rate at 30% for the moment as we evaluate BIG's operational finesse with the JWMS integration and ability to move Biomatrix sales when the CE mark arrives. Should Biosensors be an acquisition target, we deem that its deepened exposure in China along with its CE mark will bump up valuations. Maintain
*** Better don't listen too much to these analysts' TP. Could it be a pump and dump scheme? We wouldn't know. So far UBS has the most detailed research report but i beg to differ in some of his views, esp on takeover premium. Conor breached Angiotech's patent and suffering from worldwide injuction to stop sales. Costar looks promising but is a total failure in clinical trial performance. Paclitaxel drug is toxic and proven to be inferior to limus family drug. Costar's reservoir hole metal strut is a problem to achieve perfect timing of drug elusion. So far there is still no mention to the 3 main chiong factors that will happen in 2008. When the first one come, all the analysts will scamble to revise their TP higher again. We update our bottomline forecasts to factor in newBUY. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
bengster68
Master |
10-Jan-2008 17:57
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
|
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
CWQuah
Master |
10-Jan-2008 17:52
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
May the stock price chiong as much as Bengster's big post's vertical dimensions, measured in centimetres... hehe. Hope to find an opportunity to get in the next few days. Short term support probably at 97c, drop a bit because of the current sentiments and profit taking. But I personally think it's a growth stock still. Trying to get vested hahah. Caveat emptor. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
bengster68
Master |
10-Jan-2008 17:48
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
|
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
idesa168
Elite |
10-Jan-2008 17:41
|
||||
x 0
x 0 Alert Admin |
Bengster, you also make the text SO BIG!!!! | ||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me | |||||
bengster68
Master |
10-Jan-2008 17:38
|
||||
x 1
x 1 Alert Admin |
UBS Investment Research Bors International Group T ime to revisit-impending CE approval CE approval expected in Jan; acquisition of JW Medical Biosensors announced on 26th Dec that it expects CE approval for its flagship Biomatrix stent by end of Jan. 08. It also announced today that it is acquiring balance 50% stake in JW Medical. Total consideration for 100% of the company is about US$210m at an estimated P/E of under 14x (mostly payable in shares). We believe this helps Biosensors to strengthen its presence in China. Biosensor?s stent may solve the industry?s biggest concern: LST Late stent thrombosis (LST) is a key issue that the Drug Eluting Stent (DES) industry faces today. With Biosensor?s unique biodegradable polymer, and clinical trials which indicate nil LST rate, the company could get a large share of the stent market. We note however, larger trials are required to verify data provided thus far. Targeting Asian market, potential M&A target JW Medical, has a 25% share in China. Existing royalty agreement with Terumo, acquisition of PT Fondaco and recent MOU with PT Kimia Farma will also help the company market its product in Asia and Europe. Biosensors could be an attractive acquisition target after it gets the CE mark and longer term trials confirm data from smaller trials completed so far. Valuation: S$1.25 Our DCF valuation is based on a COE of 11.5% and terminal growth of 2%. We have assumed Biosensors to secure an 8% market share by FY 14. Our target valuation of US$810m is a 38% discount to acquisition price paid for Conor (a similar company to Biosensors) by Johnson & Johnson in Nov-06.
Time to revisit-impending CE
approval We believe the expected impending CE approval for Biomatrix stent could take
the share price to between S$1-1.25 and thus provides opportunity for near term
gains. Current market cap of Biosensors at about US$620m (excluding 129m
shares paid for 50% acquisition of JW Medical) compares lightly to acquisition
of Conor by J&J for US$1.3b in Nov-06. We would recommend buying the
stock for near-term gains currently. Beyond the expected near-term gains, we
believe stock value can be unlocked by: 1) being acquired by a large medical
device company, and 2) good results from large clinical trials which would be an
additional catalyst for the stock. Catalysts
announcing positive data from larger trials starting as early as this February and
announcement of further marketing tie ups in other populous countries such as
India. An acquisition offer from a large medical devices company could provide
the biggest upside. CE approval will be an important turning point for the company:
believe it may be time to revisit Biosensors as the stock has suffered on account
of delayed CE approval and negative industry newsflow (challenging safety and
efficacy of Drug Eluting stents). However, according to a press release by the
company dated 26
sometime by late January ? i.e., within the next 2-3 weeks. Also, more recent
clinical trials suggest that the drug eluting stents are safer than previous trials
suggested. Biosensor?s biodegradable polymer is key:
has not been positive, we believe with Biosensor?s unique biodegradable
polymer, it could quickly grow its turnover once receives its CE approval.
Significantly, Biosensor?s biodegradable polymer could be a potential solution
to late stent thrombosis (LST), experienced by patients who use drug eluting
stents (DES). Acquisition of JW Medical
for about US$210m at a P/E of slightly under 14x. This will result in 31%
addition to Biosensor?s outstanding shares but also bring in profit contribution.
We believe this acquisition is overall positive as Biosensors is focussed on the
Asian market which could have high growth rates over the next few years for the
stent market, unlike the developed west where the market could stagnate or
decline somewhat. Valuation and upside:
share price to reach between S$1-S$1.25 and including some premium as an
acquisition target, our price target of S$1.25 could be reached relatively near
term. We note that Biosensor?s current market cap of ~US$620m (excluding
recent US$88m increase due to JW acquisition) compares lightly to US$1.3b
paid by Johnson & Johnson for acquisition of Conor (for a similar product) in
Nov-2006
About JW Medical JW Medical was owned by Shandong Weigao, a leading manufacturer of singleuse
own branded medical devices. Shandong Weigao will be invited on the
Board of Biosensors and offered one seat. JW Medical is a drug-eluting stent
manufacturer based in Weihai, Shandong Province in China. It has received
Chinese State Food & Drug Adminsitration (SFDA) regulatory approval for its
Excel drug-eluting stent in Jan-06. According to the company, it currently has a
market share of 25% in the Chinese DES market with net profits of US$11.1m
and gross margins of atleast 75%. The company indicated that the average
selling prices of Excel is at about RMB 11,500 (cUS$1,575) compared to
imported stents from J&J for example being priced at about RMB 25,000
(cUS$3,425). Biosensors indicated that it hopes to capitalize on JW Medical?s
manufacturing facilities and capacity should the need arise. The company also
indicated that JW Medical may spend about 10-15% of its turnover for its
clinical trial program. JW Medical has also indicated that 6 months results of its
CREATE registry demonstrate the safety and efficacy of its Excel stent. The
study involves 2,077 patients in China and three other countries in South East
Asia. MACE at six months was recorded at 1.4% for this study. Impacted by delayed CE approval & industry newsflow The stock has been de-rated primarily due to delayed CE approval and some
negative industry news flow. We believe receipt of the CE approval could
provide a near term fillip to the share price:
Industry newsflow from late 2006 to early 2007 was dominated by concerns
over safety & efficacy of Drug elution stents (DES), this lead to worldwide
decline in DES sales. However some recent studies have suggested better safety
profiles for DES than initially feared; this could help pacify the initial concerns
and possibly help a recovery. Nevertheless Biosensors needs to be able to
encash on its product quickly before the next generation of stents are launched.
1) In March last year, results of COURAGE trial indicated that stents were
not really effective in reducing mortality rates and merely helped
patients to lead a better life style (lesser chest pains for example). Thus
patients could have similar mortality rates merely based on drug intake.
This led to a drop in stent utilization rates given the cost of stents.
2) Sep 2, 2007 ? (SCAI) Society for Cardiovascular Angiography and
interventions announced ?drug eluting stents are not dangerous?. The
results were based on (SCAAR) Swedish Coronary Angiography and
Angioplasty Registry which involved study of 13,000 patients for 4
years. The initial results from the same study published in 2006 had
caused major concerns over DES by reporting a 18% increased chance
of deaths among patients getting DES.
3) Oct 3, 2007 - A study funded by Ontario Ministry of health, the
Canadian Institute of health and other medical groups studied records of
over 7,000 patients treated with DES. The study concluded that patients
treated with DES were less likely to die or need repeat procedures
compared to BMS cases. These results are in direct contrast to the
COURAGE trial mentioned earlier. Further tests confirm safety of Biomatrix stent Biosensors released trials data on its Biomatrix stent on 22
term data inspires confidence in safety of the stent. The study includes findings
Table 2: Biomatrix trial results Company Product Patients Period MACE Stent thrombosis
Biosensors Biosensors Biosensors
Source: Biosensors 12-month data from the BEACON study indicated that it achieved its primary
endpoint with 2.1 percent of target vessel revascularization and a 6.5 percent
MACE rate over 180-day period and based on our conversation with the
company, we understand that there was nil rate of stent thrombosis even for the
Beacon registry. Target vessel revascularization measures any clinically-driven
repeat percutaneous revascularization or surgical bypass of the original target
lesion or any segment of the coronary artery containing the target lesion. Biodegradable ? potential solution to late stent
thrombosis? The debate over DES is about the relative long term safety of these devices
compared to bare metal stents. More specifically, these concerns relate to LST,
a sudden clotting of blood in arteries, which at times can lead to incidence like
death or heart attacks. While the cause of LST is not well established, the usage
of durable polymers is increasingly being highlighted as the possible culprit.
This is because DES are similar to BMS except for the drug and polymer coated
on to the BMS. However, as the Drug is eluted in the first six months and LST
occurs much later, the only difference between the DES and BMS is the polymer
and thus it is hypthesised that the polymer could be the key reason for LST. This
would imply stents with biodegradable polymers or biodegradable stents may be
preferred as they manage to solve the restenosis problem caused by BMS and
potentially solve the LST problem caused by most DES. Restenosis is narrowing
of arteries caused by an over-healing process after a metallic stent (recognized
as a foreign object by the body) is put in place by doctors. This over healing
leads to narrowing arteries which defeats the purpose of inserting a stent in the
body, which is to keep the arteries open. Biosensors? unique stent with biodegradable polymer;
limited competition near term The Biomatrix stent uses company?s proprietary S-stent platform, its FDA
approved Biolimus A9 drug and a biodegradable polymer. Conor?s stent,
?CoStar? was the only other commercially available bioabsorbable polymer
based stent. The product was withdrawn from market after long term clinical
trials data failed to support the positive results of earlier trials.
?ABSORB? (from Abbott Laboratories) is a fully biodegradable stent currently
under development. The initial trials for ABSORB confirm higher safety of
biodegradable stents, however we do not expect it to be commercially available
till 2012. While fully biodegradable stents are still at very nascent stage,
biodegradable polymer based stents might provide a potent solution in near term.
Biosensors as an acquisition target As stents require intensive research and regulatory approvals, the development
cycle is prolonged over years, thereby a readily marketable product commands
attention. As noted, J&J acquired Conor in Nov, 2006 for US$1.3b, primarily to
gain its CoStar stent (a similar product). At the time CoStar was approved in EU
but was pending US FDA approval. However, in May 2007 clinical trials for
CoStar failed to support the findings of its short term trials, consequently the
FDA application was withdrawn and the product was discontinued. M&A premium could be smaller for Biosensors as
compared to that for Conor 1. It is possible that Conor?s US$1.3b acquisition price was not just for
biodegradable polymer stent but also its unique stent design which could have
other applications.
2. Conor?s stent did not meet primary end points in large trials eventually
(though this could not have been known earlier) ? which led discontinuation of
the stent. This implies potential suitors for Biosensors will tread cautiously
before offering billions for a product before large clinical trials confirm the data
from the existing trials done so far. Figure 1: Restenonis rates Source: SCAAR study (Swenska Coronar Angiografi ? och Angioplastik Registret) 3. Market size has shrunk in US/ Europe due to questions on safety/efficacy.
Safety issues for DES are perhaps being addressed with larger trials but we
believe the restenosis rate differentials between BMS and DES is narrowing (see
chart above for recent data indicating just 8% restenosis rates ? as BMS
Product development Table 3: Selected product pipeline from major players Company Product Approvals Commercialization
Medtronic
expected within CY 2007
Expected in US markets in early 2008, Japan by 2009
Endeavor Resolute CE Marked Oct 2007, FDA
approval expected in FY10
Expected launch within CY07, target sales of 100,000 units in first 30
days
Edeavor Sprint CE Marked Expected US launch in 2H 08 - 1H09 JNJ
08 PMA submission in H2 2011 Abbott
approval anticipated Expected US launch In mid 2008, Japan by 2009
ABSORB None Positive 12mth data on 30 patients, but no commercialization in near
future; stent being reworked Boston
Scientific
CY08
TAXUS Liberte CE Marked To be launched in US
PROMUS element NA Under research, design expected to freeze by Q1 2008
Source: respective company data, UBS Increasing marketing and distribution network:
China, India and Indonesia Biosensors has been taking a series of measures to improve its distribution
network. It already has a royalty agreement with Japan based Terumo. We
believe Terumo can provide Biosensors with a distribution network in
particular and also in other parts of Asia and Europe. Additionally, in
company has acquired a 50% stake in JW Medical and proposes to acquire the
balance 50%. We understand JW is one of the largest suppliers of stents in the
country. Further, Biosensors also announced an MOU with P.T. Kimia Farma, a
state owned
coronary bare-metal stents and accessory products with the aim of supplying
these as choice coronary products to local government hospitals in Indonesia. In
October, it also announced acquisition of PT Fondaco Mitratama?s distribution
network (consideration for which was 5m Biosensors shares for a 70% stake) for
interventional cardiology and critical care products in Indonesia. Finally, on 2 January the company has announced formation of an
activities are related to development, manufacture, assembly and sale of medical
devices/products.
We believe it may be possible to make some gains near term as the company has
said it expects to announce its CE approval by the end of January. However,
once that?s done, unless the company is acquired, the stock could trade side
ways for the next 6-9 months. We believe ramping up of Biosensor?s
manufacturing and marketing network will take some time and after obtaining a
CE approval the company will still have to individually apply to most countries
in Europe and Asia to get approval from local regulatory authorities though in
most cases this should be merely procedural and take a few weeks to a few
months time. Once this is done, the company may be able to participate in
hospital tenders which may occur at specific times during a year. Thus it may
take some time to convert the CE approval into sales dollars. Risks We believe the two key risks with Biosensor?s biomatrix products are: 1) Larger
clinical trials do not support the safety and efficacy data indicated by the initial
clinical trial data that Biosensors has presented; and 2) Competing products (e.g.
bioabsorbable stents) hit the market much sooner than expected making
Biosensor?s Biomatrix stent obsolete. We note that CRT 2008 will have talks on
several Bioabsorbable stent programs including the Orbus Neich, REVA,
Absorbable Magnesium stents, ABSORB trial and BTI Salicylate-based
Polyanhydride Ester absorbable sirolimus-eluting stent. Valuation We value Biosensors on a discounted cash flow to equity basis using CoE of
11.5%, terminal growth of 2% and assuming the company is able to capture 8%
of DES market by FY14. Our price target of S$1.25 values the company at
US$810m (excluding US$180m to be paid to JW Medical, assumed to be value
neutral) compared to Conor?s acquisition price of US$1.3b.
We note that since our last valuation of the company, Conor?s CoStar stent has
been withdrawn from the market and the US DES market size has shrunk about
17%. However, with strong positioning in China, anticipated receipt of CE
approval (which could lead us to review our high 11.5% CoE assumption) and
recent positive industry news flow, we retain our price target. We are also
currently assuming that the JW acquisition is value neutral though this may be
overly conservative. Near-term gains could be made restenosis rates in the past have been reported to be 20% or higher) and thus the
price premium that DES commands over BMS could reduce (DES costs about
US$2,500-3,500 Vs BMS which costs about US$1,000-1,500). Thus could result
in further shrinkage of the DES market size. We understand Biosensors is also in early stages of developing a biodegradable
stent. over a period of 36 months from 120 patients treated with Biomatrix stent under
Stealth trials and indicates nil rate of stent thrombosis. Recent industry developments We believe via this transaction, Biosensors is acquiring JW's distribution
strength in China which is valuable given its strong market share. Also, JW has
a biodegradable polymer stent - and will help Biosensors ramp up production
capacity. Most companies tend to have teething problems during ramping up
production (even the bigger companies in US have had ramp up problems) - so
JW?s skills at manufacturing a stent with biodegradable polymer should be of
help to Biosensors. |
||||
Useful To Me Not Useful To Me |